Joy Osundeko, 14, lived with her family in Parr, St Helens, Merseyside. She had Down’s syndrome, pulmonary hypertension and Moyamoya syndrome, a rare condition affecting blood flow to the brain. She had a tracheostomy and could not breathe on her own, so her ventilator had to stay on at all times. Her family describe her as a much-loved daughter whose smile could light up any room; she enjoyed school and spending time with her brother Joe.
She had round-the-clock nursing care at home from Optima Health and Social Care Ltd. In 2022, after the carers arrived and her father went to bed, a nurse who had cared for her at least three times before switched off her ventilator. The family’s CCTV recorded the nurse pressing and holding a button twice and touching the screen; the machine shut down and stayed off for almost six minutes. Her mother called out that something was wrong, and her father ran downstairs to find Joy completely lifeless. He took the ventilator off her tracheostomy and bagged her by hand for almost a minute before she began breathing again. When he asked why the machine was off, the nurse kept saying she did not know and that she was sorry.
Joy spent nine days at Alder Hey Children’s Hospital. Afterwards her parents saw a marked decline: she needed more ventilation, her limbs, especially her right leg, moved much less, her general health got worse and she no longer smiled. In 2022, after being admitted to hospital as her consciousness fell, she died of a stroke that caused brainstem death.
Optima Health and Social Care admitted breaching its duty of care, said the ventilator was switched off by accident, denied that it caused injury or contributed to her death (it links her death to her underlying condition), and settled the family’s civil claim out of court. Police charged the nurse after a three-year investigation, but the Crown Prosecution Service discontinued the case in 2025, saying no wilful intent to harm could be proven. Coroner André Rebello reportedly refused the family’s request for an inquest, citing the time elapsed and her cremation. The Nursing and Midwifery Council is investigating, and the nurse is restricted to non-patient-facing roles.
She depended completely on the people paid to keep her machine running. One of them switched it off, and her family has never been told why.
Her parents link the switch-off to her death and say they have never had an explanation of why it happened. ‘What happened to her, and to us, was completely unacceptable. We feel completely failed by the system and we will keep fighting for answers,’ her mother said. They asked for an inquest, which was refused, and want the Nursing and Midwifery Council investigation to bring accountability and prevent it happening to another child.
A disabled girl’s life support was turned off by the nurse caring for her. Her parents are still waiting for answers.
Sources
- St Helens Star (Kelsey Maxwell): Company admits nurse accidentally switched off girl’s ventilator (2026)
- Medical Daily (Rohit David): Parents Call for Action After Nurse Turns Off Schoolgirl’s Ventilator for Nearly Six Minutes Leading to Her Death (2026)
- Liverpool Echo: Nurse switched off St Helens teenage girl’s life-saving machine ‘by accident’ (2026)
St Helens, England, United Kingdom · Died (not recorded as MAID) · Recorded by the register as a death caused by hospital or medical staff

Leave a Reply