Translational Analyses, Research and Advocacy

Esta Alina High was a five-month-old girl from Leeds. Her parents, Lynsey Carr and Leon High, describe her as a happy, healthy, smiling baby who completed their family.

She fell ill in 2023 with a high temperature and vomiting, and her parents took her to Leeds General Infirmary. She tested positive for Covid and was put in a side room on the children’s assessment and treatment (CAT) unit. Her parents say staff seemed more concerned with isolating her than with listening to them. They refused advice to take her home, because her temperature had soared above 40°C and she would not stop vomiting. When she developed a rash and her arm began shaking, they feared she was having a seizure; her father filmed it, and the video was shown to the inquest jury.

Doctors kept to their diagnosis of Covid. Tests for a bacterial infection were not done and antibiotics were not started. By late afternoon on 2 November she could not be roused, and scans showed meningoencephalitis caused by Streptococcus pneumoniae. She was moved to intensive care, but she died in 2023, lying between her parents. Her mother told the inquest she had been left untreated for 55 hours.

In 2026 an inquest jury at Wakefield Coroner’s Court found that Esta died of natural causes contributed to by neglect, and that different care would probably have saved or prolonged her life.

Inquest jury (Wakefield Coroner’s Court, 2026): she ‘died of natural causes contributed to by neglect’, and different care would probably have saved or prolonged her life; opportunities were missed because doctors stuck to the Covid diagnosis. The coroner is issuing a prevention of future deaths report. Lawyers for Leeds Teaching Hospitals NHS Trust admitted missed opportunities to diagnose the infection and give antibiotics. Dr Elizabeth Garthwaite, the trust’s chief medical officer, said: ‘We are deeply sorry we failed Esta and her family’ and ‘serious failures occurred in the care provided to Esta’; the trust says it has improved recognition of deteriorating children, sepsis training and escalation, and brought in Martha’s Rule.

Her parents refused to take her home and kept telling staff something was wrong. The jury found that different care would probably have saved or prolonged her life.

Her parents say their concerns were ignored until it was too late and that they were made to feel like anxious, overprotective parents. ‘We kept asking for help,’ her mother told the jury, but ‘staff were rude and don’t listen to our concerns.’ They describe her time on the CAT unit as ’15 hours filled with missed opportunities’ and are calling for parents’ concerns to be listened to and taken seriously, so that no other family goes through the same thing.

A baby died in hospital while her parents begged for someone to listen. The jury has now said it was neglect.

Sources


Leeds, England, United Kingdom · Died (not recorded as MAID) · Recorded by the register as a death caused by hospital or medical staff

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *