Translational Analyses, Research and Advocacy

Mrs A was 84 and, her family says, fit, well and independent before 2021, when she had surgery at Hawke’s Bay Hospital to remove a skin cancer from her right ear canal. She had high blood pressure, type 2 diabetes and stage 3b chronic kidney disease.

After the operation she developed a bleed in the neck wound, facial nerve palsy, wound breakdown, vocal cord palsy and trouble swallowing. Despite this, she was not referred to a dietitian or speech-language therapist until she was readmitted in September, by which time she had lost about 21 kg and was malnourished. In 2021 a feeding tube (PEG) was placed and the gastroscope perforated her oesophagus. She stayed in hospital. Her fluid balance was poorly recorded, and on 23 and 24 September she had no IV fluids.

On 25 September she was found unresponsive, with a fever and pneumonia, and blood tests showed acute kidney injury. On Sunday 26 September no doctor saw her and no blood tests were done. On 27 September her creatinine had risen to 342 (eGFR 10, kidney failure), but nobody acted on it; the kidney team was not involved until 28 September. Her daughter, Ms B, told a family meeting on 29 September that her mother’s condition was due to a series of failures in her care. On 10 October, exhausted, Mrs A declined further treatment, and she died in hospital shortly afterwards.

Health and Disability Commissioner decision CAS-13905-N4S6Q8 (Deputy Commissioner Dr Vanessa Caldwell, 2026) found Health NZ (Te Whatu Ora, Hawke’s Bay Hospital) in breach of Right 4(1) of the Code for poor coordination between specialties and for failing to monitor and act on her deteriorating kidney function on 26 and 2021. Independent adviser Dr Helen Pilmore called the failure to act on the creatinine result on 27 September a ‘severe departure’ and the missed weekend review a ‘moderate departure’, but said it was unclear whether earlier action would have changed things and that the kidney injury was unlikely to have contributed significantly to her death. The oesophageal perforation was found to be a known complication, managed appropriately. Health NZ accepted the findings and was told to apologise in writing; it says weekend junior doctor staffing and kidney-injury training have improved.

Her daughter says she was fit and independent before the operation and that a series of failures in hospital led to her death. The Commissioner found the failure to act on her kidney results was a severe departure from accepted care.

Her daughter, Ms B, complained to the Health and Disability Commissioner that systemic failures led to her mother’s deterioration and premature death: poor communication and coordination between hospital services, the perforation of her oesophagus, and poor management of her fluids, which she says caused kidney failure.

An independent woman went in for an operation and never came home. Her daughter says the hospital failed her at every step.

Sources


Hastings, Hawke’s Bay, New Zealand · Died (not recorded as MAID) · Recorded by the register as a death caused by hospital or medical staff

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *